What is the Christmas Carol Retrospective?
The Christmas Carol Retrospective is based on Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, in which three ghosts show Ebenezer Scrooge his past, his present and the future waiting for him if nothing changes. Your team takes the same tour of its own work, which makes it a natural fit for an end-of-year review. The board has three columns. Ghost of Christmas Past is for lessons from earlier work and patterns that have built up over time, such as estimates that keep slipping. Ghost of Christmas Present covers what's working and what's causing friction right now. Ghost of Christmas Future looks at the opportunities and risks ahead, and it's where you start turning the discussion into plans. The story's point is that the future isn't fixed: Scrooge changes once he's seen where he's heading. That's what the third column is for. Ask what will happen if the team carries on as it is, then decide what to change.
Christmas Carol Retrospective format
Ghost of Christmas Past
What can we learn from our previous work and experiences?
This column is for learning from the past. Ask people to think about completed work, earlier retrospectives and patterns that have built up over time. Keep it honest about successes and failures without dwelling on blame or regret.
Ghost of Christmas Present
What current challenges and successes are we experiencing?
This column is about right now: the team's current work and its immediate challenges. Ask people to be specific about what's working and what's causing friction, and save past patterns and future worries for the other two columns.
Ghost of Christmas Future
What opportunities and risks do we see ahead?
This column looks ahead. Ask about opportunities and risks, keep the discussion on concrete possibilities instead of vague hopes or fears, and start turning the most important ones into action items.
When to use this retrospective
- During end-of-year reviews, when your team is already looking back on the year and setting goals for the next.
- When you want to connect recurring patterns with current challenges and what's coming.
- After a significant organizational change, to talk about what's been lost, what's changing now and what's possible next.
- When morale needs a lift and a story-based format would help.
- For distributed teams, who can share a story most people already know.
Suggested icebreaker questions
- If you could time travel like Scrooge, which period in your team's history would you most want to revisit and why?
- What's one 'gift' (skill, insight, or support) you've received from a team member this year that you're particularly grateful for?
Want a warm-up your team plays, not just answers out loud? Browse free icebreakers →
Ideas and tips for your retrospective meeting
- Ask people to write their notes as short stories instead of isolated points.
- Balance reflection with practical action items, especially in the Ghost of Christmas Future column.
- Add a light holiday touch to the board if you like, but don't let it distract people.
- Give Ghost of Christmas Present enough time. Current issues usually produce the most discussion and the most immediate actions.
- If people struggle with Ghost of Christmas Future, prompt them with an ideal outcome or a likely risk.
- For multicultural teams, summarize the story in a minute or two before you start so everyone gets the metaphor.