Community of Practice

See whether your Community of Practice still draws people in.

Try this health check live

What is a Community of Practice health check?

A Community of Practice runs on goodwill. People show up while they're learning something and drift off when they aren't, usually without saying why. The Community of Practice health check asks members to rate five areas on a three-level scale: Knowledge Sharing, Alignment, Collaboration, Feedback, and Motivation and Fun. Each level is described in plain terms, so Knowledge Sharing runs from No sharing to Sharing thrives, and Motivation and Fun from Bored to Energized. The results show where the community is working and where a small change, such as a regular sharing slot or a clearer shared goal, could bring quieter members back in.

Dimensions

Community of Practice

Explore the health of your Community of Practice across knowledge sharing, alignment, collaboration, feedback, and motivation.

  • Knowledge Sharing

    Gauges whether members have the opportunity, means, and willingness to share and learn from one another.

    1. We do not take time to share or participate, or there are no opportunities to do so.
    2. We have limited opportunities to share knowledge.
    3. We have some sharing opportunities and can do so on occasion.

  • Alignment

    Reflects how clearly the community shares a common focus on its goals and challenges.

    1. It feels like a free for all with no synergy.
    2. Our goals rarely line up with one another.
    3. Our goals are sometimes aligned.

  • Collaboration

    Measures how effectively members work together to solve complex problems.

    1. We only work as individuals.
    2. We rarely collaborate with one another.
    3. We collaborate on an ad-hoc basis.

  • Feedback

    Assesses whether members feel safe and are encouraged to give and receive feedback.

    1. No one feels safe or is asked to give and receive feedback.
    2. Feedback is rare and not always welcomed.
    3. There are limited options to receive and give feedback.

  • Motivation and Fun

    Captures how engaged and inspired members feel to learn and grow within the community.

    1. I am bored. I don't get excited about learning something new.
    2. I rarely feel motivated to take part.
    3. I sometimes get value and motivation, but it's not consistent.

When to use this health check

  • When you're launching or growing a Community of Practice and want a baseline of its health.
  • When participation is uneven and you want to find out why.
  • At regular check-ins, to see how knowledge sharing and collaboration change over time.
  • When you suspect something is getting in the way of feedback, shared focus or motivation.

Tips & tricks

  • Run it anonymously so members can be honest about feedback safety and motivation.
  • Compare results across sessions to see whether sharing and collaboration are improving.
  • Talk about the lowest-scoring dimension first and agree on one small experiment to lift it.
  • Invite quieter members as well as regular contributors, so the results reflect the whole community.
  • Follow the check with a retrospective so what you learn turns into actions.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Community of Practice health check?
It's a short check where members of a Community of Practice rate how well the group shares knowledge, stays aligned, collaborates, exchanges feedback and keeps people motivated to learn.
Who should take part?
All members, including quieter ones as well as the most active contributors. Otherwise the results only describe the people who are already engaged.
How often should we run it?
Every quarter, or before key milestones, is a good rhythm. It lets you see how sharing, collaboration and engagement change over time.
What do the five dimensions measure?
Knowledge Sharing, Alignment, Collaboration, Feedback, and Motivation and Fun. Together they show whether members are learning from each other and want to keep coming back.
What are some example questions in a Community of Practice health check?
Each dimension is rated on a three-level scale with plain descriptions. Knowledge Sharing asks whether members have the opportunity, means and willingness to share, and runs from No sharing to Sharing thrives. Feedback asks whether members feel safe giving and receiving it, from No feedback to Safe & open.

Related health checks